This is true. But when I checked on you the other day you were fine. Happy, even, though still lonely. Now I... I can only feel hurt. *closes her eyes in pain* Piles and piles and piles of hurt, deep down inside.
*tilts his head to the side and laughs softly* And just how to you propose to fix it? Lúthien does not love me. Indeed, I think she resents me. Lúthien is not fickle. I cannot see her changing her mind easily.
*carefully* It is not something I would do for any other person. I'm not even certain I'm allowed to do it, but I know that I can. If I had been there before, on Arda, it would have been different. I would have made sure it was different. So I must fix it now.
I can change her mind for her. I can make her love you.
It would not be so far from where she is now, I think. Perhaps she does resent you, but it is not because she doesn't feel for you. All I would do is enhance those emotions and wipe away some of the bad. It would not be forcing her to do anything that would be against her nature I think. Neither of you would have to be unhappy any longer.